Guaranteed Basic Income

View previous topic View next topic Go down

Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by LooseGoose on 2017-06-04, 09:50

I would have sworn we had a discussion on this previously. Multiple searches tell me I'm wrong.

The "pure" form of this is simple. Eliminate ALL forms of aid - welfare, food stamps, home heating, etc.
Give everyone a check monthly to cover basic necessities. Let people decided where to spend that
money not government.

I'll dig some other articles up if there's any interest in this subject. Savings generated from cutting
spending programs and personnel pay for much if not all of this.

The Indestructible Idea of the Basic Income - Is this the only policy proposal Tom Paine, Huey Long, Milton Friedman, Timothy Leary, and Sam Altman can agree on?

_________________
"A nod is as good as a wink to a blind mule"
avatar
LooseGoose
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 33547
Join date : 2014-04-18
Age : 97
Location : Up North

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by Cameron on 2017-06-04, 10:56

I love the basic income idea.
avatar
Cameron
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 3355
Join date : 2014-04-16
Age : 29
Location : Michigan

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by Floyd Robertson on 2017-06-04, 11:15

538 did an article on this last year.

What Would Happen If We Just Gave People Money?

I'm not sure everyone would properly manage their basic income and then we'd have basic income plus subsidies.
avatar
Floyd Robertson
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 13394
Join date : 2014-04-15
Location : Rolling Hills

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by LooseGoose on 2017-06-04, 11:16

Couple more articles on it......there are 1000's taking both sides and various versions.
What happens if you replace every social program with a universal basic income?



Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income?

_________________
"A nod is as good as a wink to a blind mule"
avatar
LooseGoose
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 33547
Join date : 2014-04-18
Age : 97
Location : Up North

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by LooseGoose on 2017-06-04, 11:18

Floyd Robertson wrote:538 did an article on this last year.

What Would Happen If We Just Gave People Money?

I'm not sure everyone would properly manage their basic income and then we'd have basic income plus subsidies.

And the counter argument would be that many would manage the $$ for their specific needs better than the government does.

_________________
"A nod is as good as a wink to a blind mule"
avatar
LooseGoose
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 33547
Join date : 2014-04-18
Age : 97
Location : Up North

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by Floyd Robertson on 2017-06-04, 11:21

LooseGoose wrote:
Floyd Robertson wrote:538 did an article on this last year.

What Would Happen If We Just Gave People Money?

I'm not sure everyone would properly manage their basic income and then we'd have basic income plus subsidies.

And the counter argument would be that many would manage the $$ for their specific needs better than the government does.

Yep, like the 538 piece says, we won't know unless we try.
avatar
Floyd Robertson
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 13394
Join date : 2014-04-15
Location : Rolling Hills

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by DWags on 2017-06-04, 11:27

Floyd Robertson wrote:538 did an article on this last year.

What Would Happen If We Just Gave People Money?

I'm not sure everyone would properly manage their basic income and then we'd have basic income plus subsidies.

This. As unfortunate as it is we live in a country that has those not capable of helping themselves no matter what. So, how do we handle them? Say, look we gave you a check deal with it.

Mental illness, drug addiction, low iq, whatever, all play a roll in this. If SCOTUS says no more right to choose, do you think those numbers go up or down?

I'm not even a great Christian, but I think at least a little about being my brothers keeper. And save your examples of fraud and abuse. They exist and I wish all those bastards jail terms.
avatar
DWags
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 22649
Join date : 2014-04-21
Age : 55
Location : Right here

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by LooseGoose on 2017-06-04, 11:53

DWags wrote:
Floyd Robertson wrote:538 did an article on this last year.

What Would Happen If We Just Gave People Money?

I'm not sure everyone would properly manage their basic income and then we'd have basic income plus subsidies.

This. As unfortunate as it is we live in a country that has those not capable of helping themselves no matter what. So, how do we handle them? Say, look we gave you a check deal with it.

Mental illness, drug addiction, low iq, whatever, all play a roll in this. If SCOTUS says no more right to choose, do you think those numbers go up or down?

I'm not even a great Christian, but I think at least a little about being my brothers keeper. And save your examples of fraud and abuse. They exist and I wish all those bastards jail terms.

This isn't a debate about fraud since you eliminate all fraud with this proposal. Everyone gets a check so no one is gaming the system. It IS a debate over whether people will take care of themselves or not.

_________________
"A nod is as good as a wink to a blind mule"
avatar
LooseGoose
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 33547
Join date : 2014-04-18
Age : 97
Location : Up North

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by Cameron on 2017-06-04, 12:50

DWags wrote:
Floyd Robertson wrote:538 did an article on this last year.

What Would Happen If We Just Gave People Money?

I'm not sure everyone would properly manage their basic income and then we'd have basic income plus subsidies.

This. As unfortunate as it is we live in a country that has those not capable of helping themselves no matter what. So, how do we handle them? Say, look we gave you a check deal with it.

Mental illness, drug addiction, low iq, whatever, all play a roll in this. If SCOTUS says no more right to choose, do you think those numbers go up or down?

I'm not even a great Christian, but I think at least a little about being my brothers keeper. And save your examples of fraud and abuse. They exist and I wish all those bastards jail terms.

You're sounding Ben Carson-ish. "Poverty is a state of mind," that whole deal.
avatar
Cameron
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 3355
Join date : 2014-04-16
Age : 29
Location : Michigan

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by Rocinante on 2017-06-04, 12:51

This is a discussion I've had with friends for a long time. It depends on what programs are eliminated along with it. If we're talking about replacing food stamps , and housing assistance only, that's one thing. If we start saying you also have to buy your own healthcare through the capitalist market, or it's part of a voucher for public schools program, we're in a completely different place.

_________________
It's only a matter of time before this thing blows up in our faces.
avatar
Rocinante
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 11783
Join date : 2014-04-21
Location : East Lansing, MI

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by LooseGoose on 2017-06-04, 13:19

Rocinante wrote:This is a discussion I've had with friends for a long time. It depends on what programs are eliminated along with it. If we're talking about replacing food stamps , and housing assistance only, that's one thing. If we start saying you also have to buy your own healthcare through the capitalist market, or it's part of a voucher for public schools program, we're in a completely different place.

In my mind the school issue would be completely separate since the need for education wouldn't be universal or equal.

I wouldn't require the purchase of health insurance but wouldn't forbid it either. Perhaps a very basic universal coverage then you decide if you want to buy insurance that covers more?

_________________
"A nod is as good as a wink to a blind mule"
avatar
LooseGoose
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 33547
Join date : 2014-04-18
Age : 97
Location : Up North

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by Rocinante on 2017-06-04, 15:55

LooseGoose wrote:
Rocinante wrote:This is a discussion I've had with friends for a long time. It depends on what programs are eliminated along with it. If we're talking about replacing food stamps , and housing assistance only, that's one thing. If we start saying you also have to buy your own healthcare through the capitalist market, or it's part of a voucher for public schools program, we're in a completely different place.

In my mind the school issue would be completely separate since the need for education wouldn't be universal or equal.

I wouldn't require the purchase of health insurance but wouldn't forbid it either. Perhaps a very basic universal coverage then you decide if you want to buy insurance that covers more?

Now you're starting to speak my language.

_________________
It's only a matter of time before this thing blows up in our faces.
avatar
Rocinante
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 11783
Join date : 2014-04-21
Location : East Lansing, MI

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by DWags on 2017-06-04, 17:01

Cameron wrote:
DWags wrote:

This. As unfortunate as it is we live in a country that has those not capable of helping themselves no matter what. So, how do we handle them? Say, look we gave you a check deal with it.

Mental illness, drug addiction, low iq, whatever, all play a roll in this. If SCOTUS says no more right to choose, do you think those numbers go up or down?

I'm not even a great Christian, but I think at least a little about being my brothers keeper. And save your examples of fraud and abuse. They exist and I wish all those bastards jail terms.

You're sounding Ben Carson-ish. "Poverty is a state of mind," that whole deal.

The fuck? Addiction and mental illness are states of mind? Holy shit.

_________________
avatar
DWags
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 22649
Join date : 2014-04-21
Age : 55
Location : Right here

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by Cameron on 2017-06-04, 19:37

DWags wrote:
Cameron wrote:

You're sounding Ben Carson-ish. "Poverty is a state of mind," that whole deal.

The fuck? Addiction and mental illness are states of mind? Holy shit.

Your jimmies are so easy to rustle.

And I would say that mental illness is, by definition, a state of mind.
avatar
Cameron
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 3355
Join date : 2014-04-16
Age : 29
Location : Michigan

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by Rocinante on 2017-06-04, 19:46

How about eliminating social security along with this? I say absolutely.

_________________
It's only a matter of time before this thing blows up in our faces.
avatar
Rocinante
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 11783
Join date : 2014-04-21
Location : East Lansing, MI

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by Floyd Robertson on 2017-06-04, 20:16

Rocinante wrote:How about eliminating social security along with this?  I say absolutely.

I have no problem if you want to phase it out after I collect all my benefits and I'm ashes.
avatar
Floyd Robertson
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 13394
Join date : 2014-04-15
Location : Rolling Hills

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by WhiteBoyHatcher on 2017-06-04, 20:21

The owners of the 3 casinos in Detroit would love this plan.

_________________
Yeah, well....I *also* cook.
avatar
WhiteBoyHatcher
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 15834
Join date : 2014-04-20
Location : Yeah, well....I *also* cook.

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by LooseGoose on 2017-06-04, 20:39

Rocinante wrote:How about eliminating social security along with this? I say absolutely.

It would have the political benefit of not having to "fix" it. Obviously it would also free an enormous pot of $$ to raise the GBI


_________________
"A nod is as good as a wink to a blind mule"
avatar
LooseGoose
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 33547
Join date : 2014-04-18
Age : 97
Location : Up North

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by LooseGoose on 2017-06-06, 09:30


_________________
"A nod is as good as a wink to a blind mule"
avatar
LooseGoose
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 33547
Join date : 2014-04-18
Age : 97
Location : Up North

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by Watch Out Pylon! on 2017-06-06, 10:42


I'm not sure if you're for or against this Goose, but guaranteed jobs is textbook communism. Are you a communist now? If so, that makes zombie Reagan sad. :(
avatar
Watch Out Pylon!
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 11973
Join date : 2014-04-30

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by Rocinante on 2017-06-06, 11:49

Watch Out Pylon! wrote:

I'm not sure if you're for or against this Goose, but guaranteed jobs is textbook communism. Are you a communist now? If so, that makes zombie Reagan sad. :(

Don't question it. Just try to hold on to the places where agreement can be reached.

_________________
It's only a matter of time before this thing blows up in our faces.
avatar
Rocinante
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 11783
Join date : 2014-04-21
Location : East Lansing, MI

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by Floyd Robertson on 2017-06-10, 07:14

avatar
Floyd Robertson
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 13394
Join date : 2014-04-15
Location : Rolling Hills

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by Rocinante on 2017-06-10, 12:27

More like "job-free" future, amirite?

#videogames247

_________________
It's only a matter of time before this thing blows up in our faces.
avatar
Rocinante
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 11783
Join date : 2014-04-21
Location : East Lansing, MI

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by LooseGoose on 2017-08-14, 08:46

Rocinante wrote:More like "job-free" future, amirite?

#videogames247

This guy thinks so...

Why a Universal Basic Income Would Be a Calamity

_________________
"A nod is as good as a wink to a blind mule"
avatar
LooseGoose
Geronte
Geronte

Posts : 33547
Join date : 2014-04-18
Age : 97
Location : Up North

Back to top Go down

Re: Guaranteed Basic Income

Post by msugolfguy on 2017-08-14, 09:10

LooseGoose wrote:I would have sworn we had a discussion on this previously. Multiple searches tell me I'm wrong.

The "pure" form of this is simple. Eliminate ALL forms of aid - welfare, food stamps, home heating, etc.
Give everyone a check monthly to cover basic necessities. Let people decided where to spend that
money not government.

I'll dig some other articles up if there's any interest in this subject. Savings generated from cutting
spending programs and personnel pay for much if not all of this.

The Indestructible Idea of the Basic Income - Is this the only policy proposal Tom Paine, Huey Long, Milton Friedman, Timothy Leary, and Sam Altman can agree on?

This idea I'm ok with. I would also throw in means based testing as well.
avatar
msugolfguy
Spartiate

Posts : 173
Join date : 2014-08-25

Back to top Go down

View previous topic View next topic Back to top


 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum