Would you let your 5 year old son....

by **WhiteBoyHatcher** 2014-09-13, 23:38

....be a Disney Princess for Halloween?

Serious question. I'm sure I will get plenty of smart ass replies.

He wants to be Elsa. It's all he talks about. I'm struggling with it. I know the social environment I grew up in. Something like that would probably have been prime for ridicule even in preschool and your buddies would hold it against you probably through High School. I don't want my kid being bullied. But things are different now. I also want him to be secure and confident and don't want to give off signals like I disapprove of that. Do what you want, in a way.

Kids are goofy. All the kids in his preschool are apparently obsessed with Frozen. He's also obsessed with TMNT and Jake and TNLP and other stuff. But Frozen is his current thing and he really wants to be Elsa. He is probably going to get exposed to other kids when he gets to K next year and I will miss the days when he thought it was cool to like different stuff.

But dressing in drag? I just don't know if I can go through with it. Am I being stupid? I mean it's a 4/5 year old, right?

If you offer a serious response here (doubtful), I want your age, and # of kids.

by **InTenSity** 2014-09-13, 23:44

Frozen is a weird obsessive kid movie. When in mi I visited my best friend who has 2 boys. 2 and 5. I was very surprised to hear that frozen is their favorite movie. Why not suggest Olaf or...Sven?

by **WhiteBoyHatcher** 2014-09-13, 23:48

InTenSity wrote:Frozen is a weird obsessive kid movie. When in mi I visited my best friend who has 2 boys. 2 and 5. I was very surprised to hear that frozen is their favorite movie. Why not suggest Olaf or...Sven?

Tried.

He wants Elsa. He is such a stubborn motherfucker.

I told my wife can we wait a few weeks? These kids change their obsessions every 2-3 weeks it seems. He might be totally over it. Wife is freaking out and feeling guilty for telling him we weren't buying the Elsa costume at Target today. Neutral

by **InTenSity** 2014-09-13, 23:51

I don't have an answer. My son has downs, I'm not going to worry about what he wears for Halloween. Start putting star wars on whenever he's around. Yes, start with ep1.

by **NigelUno** 2014-09-14, 00:03

Elsa? Isn't that the mother lion in Born Free?

Lions are cool.

by **InTenSity** 2014-09-14, 00:04

NigelUno wrote:Elsa? Isn't that the mother lion in Born Free?Lions are cool.

Elsa is the younger sister and main character for frozen. Ana is the older sister.

by **NigelUno** 2014-09-14, 00:07

InTenSity wrote:
Elsa is the younger sister and main character for frozen. Ana is the older sister.

Oh. I have no idea about any of that Frozen stuff.

I wouldn't let my kid dress up as a girl though.

by **InTenSity** 2014-09-14, 00:09

NigelUno wrote:InTenSity wrote:“Elsa is the younger sister and main character for frozen. Ana is the older sister.”Oh. I have no idea about any of that Frozen stuff.I wouldn't let my kid dress up as a girl though.

Do you have kids? There was a lot of things my kids couldn't do, before they were born.

by **NigelUno** 2014-09-14, 00:12

InTenSity wrote:

Do you have kids? There was a lot of things my kids couldn't do, before they were born.

Yes. Not really Halloween dress up age any more. My sis in law dressed up her boy (probably around 5) in some Peter Pan (really, Peter Pan?) outfit one year, but the kid looked like TinkerBell. We all still laugh about it.

by **WhiteBoyHatcher** 2014-09-14, 00:14

My son was Peter Pan last year. It was his obsession at the time. Actually Peter Pan is pretty awesome. Not sure how he got the rep that he did.

by **NigelUno** 2014-09-14, 00:15

WhiteBoyHatcher wrote:My son was Peter Pan last year. It was his obsession at the time. Actually Peter Pan is pretty awesome. Not sure how he got the rep that he did.

Tinkerbell though?

by LoneWolfSparty 2014-09-14, 00:27

Hecks no. You need to get him into trucks and toy guns and cowboys and Indians. Stat.

by **WhiteBoyHatcher** 2014-09-14, 00:30

LoneWolfSparty wrote:Hecks no. You need to get him into trucks and toy guns and cowboys and Indians. Stat.

lol. Was particularly interested to hear your response.

He's been into all of those things at various times. Right now he's into Frozen. I'm torn, like Natalie Imbruglia.

by **y2kMgrad** 2014-09-14, 00:35

I would probably just tell him he's being silly because Elsa is a girl's costume and he should pick a boy one. Then show him some cool boy costumes like yoda or something.

by **pulling69** 2014-09-14, 00:41

Yoda? About it tell me:

by **GirbaudJeans** 2014-09-14, 00:41

I would just tell him that spending too much time with mommy is making him gay. Dress him up as that yodeling asshole you bought recently.

by **DWags** 2014-09-14, 00:44

WhiteBoyHatcher wrote:....be a Disney Princess for Halloween?

Serious question. I'm sure I will get plenty of smart ass replies.

He wants to be Elsa. It's all he talks about. I'm struggling with it. I know the social environment I grew up in. Something like that would probably have been prime for ridicule even in preschool and your buddies would hold it against you probably through High School. I don't want my kid being bullied. But things are different now. I also want him to be secure and confident and don't want to give off signals like I disapprove of that. Do what you want, in a way.

Kids are goofy. All the kids in his preschool are apparently obsessed with Frozen. He's also obsessed with TMNT and Jake and TNLP and other stuff. But Frozen is his current thing and he really wants to be Elsa. He is probably going to get exposed to other kids when he gets to K next year and I will miss the days when he thought it was cool to like different stuff.

But dressing in drag? I just don't know if I can go through with it. Am I being stupid? I mean it's a 4/5 year old, right?

If you offer a serious response here (doubtful), I want your age, and # of kids.

Daughters 17 & 14. They were everything on Halloween growing up at that age. They were dalmations, they were football players, they were princesses, they were Winny the pooh. I think they're pretty well adjusted now. They aren't bears, they aren't dogs, they aren't princesses. I think you let kids that age do whatever the hell they want. They aren't dressing in drag cause they wasn't to be a woman or whatever. They just love lthe movies and shit like that.

I need to qualify this with what I always do however, I'm probably the worst ****ing parent ever made. I wake up clueless, I don't know how to discipline them or when to, I have no clue what I should do a lot of the day. I'm pretty lucky they both kind of take care of themselves. Oh, and their mom seems to know how to handle a lot of shit that comes up in their lives. I just kind of talk football with them.

by **Cym Jim** 2014-09-14, 01:05

WhiteBoyHatcher wrote:....be a Disney Princess for Halloween?

Serious question. I'm sure I will get plenty of smart ass replies.

He wants to be Elsa. It's all he talks about. I'm struggling with it. I know the social environment I grew up in. Something like that would probably have been prime for ridicule even in preschool and your buddies would hold it against you probably through High School. I don't want my kid being bullied. But things are different now. I also want him to be secure and confident and don't want to give off signals like I disapprove of that. Do what you want, in a way.

Kids are goofy. All the kids in his preschool are apparently obsessed with Frozen. He's also obsessed with TMNT and Jake and TNLP and other stuff. But Frozen is his current thing and he really wants to be Elsa. He is probably going to get exposed to other kids when he gets to K next year and I will miss the days when he thought it was cool to like different stuff.

But dressing in drag? I just don't know if I can go through with it. Am I being stupid? I mean it's a 4/5 year old, right?

If you offer a serious response here (doubtful), I want your age, and # of kids.

LGBTQ tendencies are usually apparent at very early ages - so you can either try to force "him" into a lifestyle where he will feel uncomfortable and depressed, or celebrate who he is and let him explore a transvestite or transgendered lifestyle.

My son was kicking ass in sports at your boy's age and tested into the best selective elementary in the state, so I can't really empathize. However, I like to think I might have been able to love him just as much if he had "developed" like your "boy". I hate people who are judgmental. Send me a PM if I can help further.

by **xsanguine** 2014-09-14, 01:14

by **Rocinante** 2014-09-14, 01:26

Let him. Who cares? It's your insecurity that's on display here and it's not your costume. So ask yourself, what's worse, a boy that wants to dress up like a girl with awesome ice powers, or a dad that worries about how that will make HIM look?

by **xsanguine** 2014-09-14, 01:31

He just doesn't want to walk in on what will be his 15 year old son giving his "best friend" a bro-job in 10 years.

by SpartanGuard 2014-09-14, 01:39

InTenSity wrote:
Elsa is the younger sister and main character for frozen. Ana is the older sister.

First off, flip that around: Elsa is the older sister.

But in all seriousness, let him be what he wants to be. I agree that it can't hurt to wait a few weeks, so he can be really sure that's what he wants to be (it's only the second week of September, after all), but if that's what he's set on, go for it. Maybe Elsa in pants? And if he's in preschool, then it's less likely to follow him should he become embarrassed by it down the line.

by **NigelUno** 2014-09-14, 07:26

Cym Jim wrote:
LGBTQ tendencies are usually apparent at very early ages - so you can either try to force "him" into a lifestyle where he will feel uncomfortable and depressed, or celebrate who he is and let him explore a transvestite or transgendered lifestyle.

My son was kicking ass in sports at your boy's age and tested into the best selective elementary in the state, so I can't really empathize. However, I like to think I might have been able to love him just as much if he had "developed" like your "boy". I hate people who are judgmental. Send me a PM if I can help further.

Would you let your 5 year old son.... 502811600

by LoneWolfSparty 2014-09-14, 08:50

WhiteBoyHatcher wrote:LoneWolfSparty wrote:“Hecks no. You need to get him into trucks and toy guns and cowboys and Indians. Stat.”lol. Was particularly interested to hear your response. He's been into all of those things at various times. Right now he's into Frozen. I'm torn, like Natalie Imbruglia.

Mmmm. Natalie Imbruglia...... There were a few things on her a wanted to torn back in the day.....

by LoneWolfSparty 2014-09-14, 08:52

Cym Jim wrote:WhiteBoyHatcher wrote:“....be a Disney Princess for Halloween?Serious question. I'm sure I will get plenty of smart ass replies. He wants to be Elsa. It's all he talks about. I'm struggling with it. I know the social environment I grew up in. Something like that would probably have been prime for ridicule even in preschool and your buddies would hold it against you probably through High School. I don't want my kid being bullied. But things are different now. I also want him to be secure and confident and don't want to give off signals like I disapprove of that. Do what you want, in a way. Kids are goofy. All the kids in his preschool are apparently obsessed with Frozen. He's also obsessed with TMNT and Jake and TNLP and other stuff. But Frozen is his current thing and he really wants to be Elsa. He is probably going to get exposed to other kids when he gets to K next year and I will miss the days when he thought it was cool to like different stuff. But dressing in drag? I just don't know if I can go through with it. Am I being stupid? I mean it's a 4/5 year old, right?If you offer a serious response here (doubtful), I want your age, and # of kids. ”LGBTQ tendencies are usually apparent at very early ages - so you can either try to force "him" into a lifestyle where he will feel uncomfortable and depressed, or celebrate who he is and let him explore a transvestite or transgendered lifestyle. My son was kicking ass in sports at your boy's age and tested into the best selective elementary in the state, so I can't really empathize. However, I like to think I might have been able to love him just as much if he had "developed" like your "boy". I hate people who are judgmental. Send me a PM if I can help further.

Says the biggest most judgmental tool ever! LOL

by Spartan Pride 2014-09-14, 09:47

Penniman's sexual orientation has long been a topic of debate. Penniman claimed that as a child he felt feminine and played with girls, which was the source of jokes at his expense.[120] Caught wearing his mother's makeup and wardrobe at times, he was brutally punished by his father.[121] Penniman began having sexual encounters with both sexes by his early teens.[122] Allegedly due to his effeminate mannerisms, Penniman's father kicked him out of their family home at 15.[2] Penniman first became involved in voyeurism in his early twenties, when a female friend of his would drive around and pick up men who would allow him to watch them have sex in the backseat of cars. Penniman was once arrested after a gas station attendant in Macon reported sexual activity in a car featuring Penniman and a couple.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Richard

by **NigelUno** 2014-09-14, 09:56

Seriously. Just let him dress up as a football player.

I think Adrian Peterson jerseys are pretty cheap right now.

by HT 2014-09-14, 09:59

23 and no kids. I guess you just let him wear what he wants, as there's no harm done if he's in preschool. Still plenty of time until Halloween, too, and he might end up changing his mind to something that you're more comfortable with.

Worse comes to worst, though, he dresses as a princess and it's something you and him can laugh about when you look back on things, and I'm sure he'll have more fun and have a better lasting impression of Halloween if you let him wear what he wants instead of pressing a different costume on him.

Also...if you ever worry about him getting made fun of, you just gotta teach the value of shrugging things off sometimes and not letting others get to him, and that's a lesson better taught early.

by Brock Middlebrook 2014-09-14, 10:10

I'm sure he'll make a fabulous princess

Would you let your 5 year old son.... O-PRINCESS-HALLOWEEN-facebook

by Izzo Court 2014-09-14, 10:14

All the kids want to be Elsa because she shoots ice and freezes stuff, so I can understand why a boy would want to go as Queen Elsa and not Princess Anna.

I would be patient and watch the Avengers, Captain America, and Thor as much as possible. It's not a big deal if he goes as a Disney Princess, but when he's 16 and the pictures of him dressed up as Elsa make their way out he will wish he went as Thor.

by **CORNER BLITZ** 2014-09-14, 11:10

Izzo Court wrote:All the kids want to be Elsa because she shoots ice and freezes stuff, so I can understand why a boy would want to go as Queen Elsa and not Princess Anna.

I would be patient and watch the Avengers, Captain America, and Thor as much as possible. It's not a big deal if he goes as a Disney Princess, but when he's 16 and the pictures of him dressed up as Elsa make their way out he will wish he went as Thor.

I'd agree with this. Not the end of the world right now, when he has pictures of it at his HS graduation he'll probably be upset you 1) dressed him like that 2) have pictures of it to put up at his grad party.

You ever go with him to see the new TMNT movie?

edit - 0 wife, 0 kids, 1-one year old nephew that likes Pitch Perfect because of all the music he can dance to

by **CORNER BLITZ** 2014-09-14, 11:18

show him the Rocketeer and make this

Would you let your 5 year old son.... Somepe10

by **Turtleneck** 2014-09-14, 11:19

NigelUno wrote:

Oh. I have no idea about any of that Frozen stuff.

I wouldn't let my kid dress up as a girl though.

But it is ok for you to wear yoga pants?

by **Floyd Robertson** 2014-09-14, 11:44

CORNER BLITZ wrote:show him the Rocketeer and make this

As a huge fan of that movie, I cant tell you how awesome that is.

Also, show him Jenny Blake.
Would you let your 5 year old son.... Jenny

by **CORNER BLITZ** 2014-09-14, 11:59

Floyd Robertson wrote:

As a huge fan of that movie, I cant tell you how awesome that is.

Also, show him Jenny Blake.

Exactly, loved that movie as a kid and always wanted to fly so the thought of making a jet-pack was amazing

Also if he doesn't fall for dem titties, then you'll know he wants to wear the skirt for more than just super powers NTTAWWT
Would you let your 5 year old son.... IcuSigIx2sf3Q

Would you let your 5 year old son.... IcuSigIx2sf3Q

by SPARTASOTAN 2014-09-14, 18:20

Any trees in your yard?
Can't think of a better instance to use a switch.

by Uno Nigel 2014-09-14, 18:25

WhiteBoyHatcher wrote:....be a Disney Princess for Halloween?

Serious question. I'm sure I will get plenty of smart ass replies.

He wants to be Elsa. It's all he talks about. I'm struggling with it. I know the social environment I grew up in. Something like that would probably have been prime for ridicule even in preschool and your buddies would hold it against you probably through High School. I don't want my kid being bullied. But things are different now. I also want him to be secure and confident and don't want to give off signals like I disapprove of that. Do what you want, in a way.

Kids are goofy. All the kids in his preschool are apparently obsessed with Frozen. He's also obsessed with TMNT and Jake and TNLP and other stuff. But Frozen is his current thing and he really wants to be Elsa. He is probably going to get exposed to other kids when he gets to K next year and I will miss the days when he thought it was cool to like different stuff.

But dressing in drag? I just don't know if I can go through with it. Am I being stupid? I mean it's a 4/5 year old, right?

If you offer a serious response here (doubtful), I want your age, and # of kids.

I think that is adorable. Boys at that age don't understand gender differences and right now his Mother is probably having more influence on his feelings as Dad is busy at work and BBqing. I wouldn't worry about it, he will actually grow out of it. I used to play with my sisters Barbies with her until one day I got the urge to play army with my guy friends when I was about 7 and never went back to Barbie again.

by Uno Nigel 2014-09-14, 18:26

Cym Jim wrote:
LGBTQ tendencies are usually apparent at very early ages - so you can either try to force "him" into a lifestyle where he will feel uncomfortable and depressed, or celebrate who he is and let him explore a transvestite or transgendered lifestyle.

My son was kicking ass in sports at your boy's age and tested into the best selective elementary in the state, so I can't really empathize. However, I like to think I might have been able to love him just as much if he had "developed" like your "boy". I hate people who are judgmental. Send me a PM if I can help further.

Would you let your 5 year old son.... 1966794946

so cruel.

by MSU addict 2014-09-14, 21:22

When I was around 8 my Mom essentially forced me to be a ballerina one Halloween. By forced I mean it was a simple ultimatum - be a ballerina or not go out trick or treating. As I remember it, I still refused, but then she up the ante by offering me $5. This was more than forty years ago and I grew up poor in a very working class neighborhood so $5 was a small fortune to me. I took the money.

Kids have short memories, so other than the next week no one at school teased me. It is not something that carried on into high school or anything past elementary school.

Any continual taunting has really comes from my family. Again, this was more than 40 year ago so the thought of taking a picture with a phone was beyond comprehension. Somehow a picture of me in the costume do seem to show up at a strange number of family gatherings. My sister (who is seven years younger than me) for some reason still thinks it is hilarious and is the main perpetrator.

If I were in your shoes, I would try my best to redirect him but it sounds like it may have become a battle of wills. Unfortunately, he is probably too young to bribe.

To answer your other question, I am 50 and have one child, a 5 month old daughter (yeah, I am old).

by **Rocinante** 2014-09-14, 21:24

Damn man. Starting late aren't you, old balls?

by Sponsored content