Immigration reform?
+8
Floyd Robertson
AvgMSUJoe
Trapper Gus
GRR Spartan
NigelUno
Turtleneck
Dr. Strangelove
CheesySpartan
12 posters
Page 1 of 1
Immigration reform?
http://www.cnn.com/2014/11/20/politics/obama-immigration-speech/index.html?hpt=hp_t1
I'm trying to figure out what benefits the POTUS is granting with this executive order? If this article is correct it appears that he is simply "kicking the can" for three years till he is out of office.
Who will this help long term? It does not make anyone a citizen nor put them on a path to citizenship. It does not allow anyone to access government programs.
I'm trying to figure out what benefits the POTUS is granting with this executive order? If this article is correct it appears that he is simply "kicking the can" for three years till he is out of office.
Who will this help long term? It does not make anyone a citizen nor put them on a path to citizenship. It does not allow anyone to access government programs.
CheesySpartan- Spartiate
- Posts : 2534
Join date : 2014-05-16
Location : SwillinatI Ch33sySpartan
Re: Immigration reform?
It's a feel good sop to his base and a provocation to the GOP.
I don't see why vast numbers of illegal aliens would try to take advantage of Obama's executive "amnesty". Why would they register here with the government on the basis of an executive order that will be surely be overturned in the case of the GOP President. That information could then be used to round up illegals. Now you might argue that the GOP could lose in 16 and of course they could.
So maybe an illegal would take advantage of Obama's order then? Not so sure they want to go to through the hassle associated and also expose themselves to paying processing fees and taxes.
From a practical matter it would just be easier and cheaper to remain illegal and continue going about your business.
I don't see why vast numbers of illegal aliens would try to take advantage of Obama's executive "amnesty". Why would they register here with the government on the basis of an executive order that will be surely be overturned in the case of the GOP President. That information could then be used to round up illegals. Now you might argue that the GOP could lose in 16 and of course they could.
So maybe an illegal would take advantage of Obama's order then? Not so sure they want to go to through the hassle associated and also expose themselves to paying processing fees and taxes.
From a practical matter it would just be easier and cheaper to remain illegal and continue going about your business.
Dr. Strangelove- Geronte
- Posts : 3930
Join date : 2014-05-15
Location : Dixie
Re: Immigration reform?
Maine Town Resorts To Hiring Americans As Visas Run Out
Higher wages attract more and better workers… it’s really that simple. And if that enhanced compensation package is attracting more employees locally, why are you relying on the H-2B program to begin with? Remember that one of the requirements for a business to qualify to use H-2B workers is as follows:Employing H-2B workers will not adversely affect the wages and working conditions of similarly employed U.S. workers.
If you can make your business model work during the busiest season by offering a better compensation package but you’re bringing in foreign workers who will do the job for less, isn’t that sort of undermining the purported reason for the program’s existence? There may not be enough locals around Bar Harbor to fill all of these seasonal jobs, but the employers there have been forced to take some actions which they might have considered before running out of visa holders.
Guest- Guest
Re: Immigration reform?
The Department of Homeland Security on Monday announced a one-time increase of 15,000 additional visas for low-wage, seasonal workers for the remainder of this fiscal year, a seeming about-face from President Trump's "Hire American" rhetoric, following heavy lobbying from the fisheries, hospitality and other industries that rely on temporary foreign workers.
The increase represents a 45 percent bump from the number of H-2B visas normally issued for the second half of the fiscal year, said senior Homeland Security officials in a call with reporters Monday.
The visas are for workers taking temporary jobs in the seafood, tourism, landscaping, construction and other seasonal industries -- but not farm laborers.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/07/17/trump-officials-order-15000-new-visas-for-low-wage-workers/?utm_term=.8957876f4f01
Turtleneck- Geronte
- Posts : 42806
Join date : 2014-04-22
Re: Immigration reform?
LooseGoose wrote:Maine Town Resorts To Hiring Americans As Visas Run OutHigher wages attract more and better workers… it’s really that simple. And if that enhanced compensation package is attracting more employees locally, why are you relying on the H-2B program to begin with? Remember that one of the requirements for a business to qualify to use H-2B workers is as follows:
If you can make your business model work during the busiest season by offering a better compensation package but you’re bringing in foreign workers who will do the job for less, isn’t that sort of undermining the purported reason for the program’s existence? There may not be enough locals around Bar Harbor to fill all of these seasonal jobs, but the employers there have been forced to take some actions which they might have considered before running out of visa holders.
You seem to be ignoring that businesses (including Trump's) would rather have cheaper labor.
The lack of cheap foreign labor is essentially raising the minimum wage (something which I don't think you're in favor of). Seems to be a contradiction.
NigelUno- Geronte
- Posts : 35261
Join date : 2014-04-16
Re: Immigration reform?
Has Trump replaced all the service workers at his hotels, golf resorts or winery working there with visa's with home grown US citizens?
http://www.thedailybeast.com/a-visa-banbut-not-for-trumps-foreign-workers
http://www.thedailybeast.com/a-visa-banbut-not-for-trumps-foreign-workers
GRR Spartan- Geronte
- Posts : 11144
Join date : 2014-04-25
Re: Immigration reform?
The significant downturn in the number of illegal border crossers between the U.S. and Mexico is "nothing short of miraculous," National Border Patrol Council President Brandon Judd said on C-SPAN Monday.
"As far as the Trump administration's efforts on immigration, this is something they campaigned heavily on," he said. "At six months, where we are on meeting those promises, we are seeing nothing short of miraculous. If you look at the rhetoric that President Trump has given, it has caused a number of illegal border crossings to go down. We have never seen such a drop that we currently have."
"There's a vibe, there's an energy in the Border Patrol that's never been there before in 20 years that I've been in the patrol," Judd added in a separate Fox News interview.
This month, Customs and Border Protection reported a 53 percent decrease in the number of apprehensions at the southwest border since last year. The number also includes those deemed inadmissible. CBP sees apprehensions as a proxy for how many people are trying to cross the border, and says the drop in apprehensions indicates a drop in attempted illegal crossings.
Judd said the Trump administration commanded in two executive orders for border agents to fully carry out related laws, while the Obama administration kept agents from doing their jobs as was intended.
Border Patrol union chief praises 'miraculous' drop in illegal immigration under Trump
Guest- Guest
Re: Immigration reform?
LooseGoose wrote:The significant downturn in the number of illegal border crossers between the U.S. and Mexico is "nothing short of miraculous," National Border Patrol Council President Brandon Judd said on C-SPAN Monday.
"As far as the Trump administration's efforts on immigration, this is something they campaigned heavily on," he said. "At six months, where we are on meeting those promises, we are seeing nothing short of miraculous. If you look at the rhetoric that President Trump has given, it has caused a number of illegal border crossings to go down. We have never seen such a drop that we currently have."
"There's a vibe, there's an energy in the Border Patrol that's never been there before in 20 years that I've been in the patrol," Judd added in a separate Fox News interview.
This month, Customs and Border Protection reported a 53 percent decrease in the number of apprehensions at the southwest border since last year. The number also includes those deemed inadmissible. CBP sees apprehensions as a proxy for how many people are trying to cross the border, and says the drop in apprehensions indicates a drop in attempted illegal crossings.
Judd said the Trump administration commanded in two executive orders for border agents to fully carry out related laws, while the Obama administration kept agents from doing their jobs as was intended.
Border Patrol union chief praises 'miraculous' drop in illegal immigration under Trump
How's the wall coming along?
NigelUno- Geronte
- Posts : 35261
Join date : 2014-04-16
Re: Immigration reform?
NigelUno wrote:LooseGoose wrote:
Border Patrol union chief praises 'miraculous' drop in illegal immigration under Trump
How's the wall coming along?
It's almost done. They just have to add a few more windows.
Turtleneck- Geronte
- Posts : 42806
Join date : 2014-04-22
Re: Immigration reform?
https://www.axios.com/2024/04/28/immigration-crisis-economy-jobs-market-workers
It really is too bad that the Republicans are using this as a political whipping boy.
It really is too bad that the Republicans are using this as a political whipping boy.
Re: Immigration reform?
Not sure where to throw this... Brown people bad? Paying Brown people bad?
Michigan farmers squeezed by wage hikes under migrant worker program
Michigan farmers squeezed by wage hikes under migrant worker program
AvgMSUJoe- Geronte
- Posts : 11830
Join date : 2014-04-22
Location : As stupid and vicious as men are, this is a lovely day.
Re: Immigration reform?
AvgMSUJoe wrote:Not sure where to throw this... Brown people bad? Paying Brown people bad?
Michigan farmers squeezed by wage hikes under migrant worker program
I'm really starting the think that capitalism is a stupid idea. We're just perpetually locked in a cycle of workers wanting higher wages to afford the things that corporate America raises the prices on, which then causes corporations to raise prices again. I mean, a dollar in 1970 is worth about 20 million now. Unfortunately, it's still the best system we got.
Floyd Robertson- Geronte
- Posts : 29705
Join date : 2014-04-15
Location : Rolling Hills Alcoholic Rehabilitation Center: Where They Don't Beat You or Anything
Cameron likes this post
Re: Immigration reform?
Floyd Robertson wrote:AvgMSUJoe wrote:Not sure where to throw this... Brown people bad? Paying Brown people bad?
Michigan farmers squeezed by wage hikes under migrant worker program
I'm really starting the think that capitalism is a stupid idea. We're just perpetually locked in a cycle of workers wanting higher wages to afford the things that corporate America raises the prices on, which then causes corporations to raise prices again. I mean, a dollar in 1970 is worth about 20 million now. Unfortunately, it's still the best system we got.
It’s been all downhill since the U.S. went off the gold standard.
TravelinMan- Geronte
- Posts : 2497
Join date : 2014-04-16
Re: Immigration reform?
every now and then I consider tuning into the mainstream media just to find out what I'm supposed to be outraged at.
Robert J Sakimano- Geronte
- Posts : 52014
Join date : 2014-04-15
Re: Immigration reform?
Ps. Long story short I went to the drive through car wash last Friday, and there's a sign hanging near the entrance, now hiring $16.50 an hour. I found my part-time retirement job when I hit that milestone.
Floyd Robertson- Geronte
- Posts : 29705
Join date : 2014-04-15
Location : Rolling Hills Alcoholic Rehabilitation Center: Where They Don't Beat You or Anything
Robert J Sakimano likes this post
Re: Immigration reform?
TravelinMan wrote:Floyd Robertson wrote:
I'm really starting the think that capitalism is a stupid idea. We're just perpetually locked in a cycle of workers wanting higher wages to afford the things that corporate America raises the prices on, which then causes corporations to raise prices again. I mean, a dollar in 1970 is worth about 20 million now. Unfortunately, it's still the best system we got.
It’s been all downhill since the U.S. went off the gold standard.
On the positive side we have managed to avoid those pesky depressions being on a limited supply fixed commodity based monetary standard, such as the gold standard, create.
Re: Immigration reform?
I will be fully vested in 6 years.. probably hang around for another year or two after that.Floyd Robertson wrote:Ps. Long story short I went to the drive through car wash last Friday, and there's a sign hanging near the entrance, now hiring $16.50 an hour. I found my part-time retirement job when I hit that milestone.
I'll need retirement job to keep from driving my wife crazy, so hopefully they're still hiring then.
Robert J Sakimano- Geronte
- Posts : 52014
Join date : 2014-04-15
Floyd Robertson and Trapper Gus like this post
Re: Immigration reform?
important to remember:
a) republicans/libertarians are to blame for their manufactured "open border" or "filthy illegal immigrant" crisis.
and..
b) I'd much rather live next door to a family of immigrants than a family of republicans/libertarians.
a) republicans/libertarians are to blame for their manufactured "open border" or "filthy illegal immigrant" crisis.
and..
b) I'd much rather live next door to a family of immigrants than a family of republicans/libertarians.
Robert J Sakimano- Geronte
- Posts : 52014
Join date : 2014-04-15
Trapper Gus likes this post
Re: Immigration reform?
The anti - immigrant people in this country remind me of the rich people who want to eliminate all the support systems that helped them get rich.
Plus, without immigrants the economy would be in the dumps.
Plus, without immigrants the economy would be in the dumps.
Robert J Sakimano likes this post
Re: Immigration reform?
Trapper Gus wrote:The anti - immigrant people in this country remind me of the rich people who want to eliminate all the support systems that helped them get rich.
Plus, without immigrants the economy would be in the dumps.
My argument for a progressive tax policy is somewhat analogous. On taxes, it is the rich need to pay more because they have the most to lose when society collapses. With immigrants, it is we need to be accommodating because no one is going to do the jobs we need to keep our society from collapsing.
gomersbro- Spartiate
- Posts : 803
Join date : 2014-04-23
Age : 23
Location : Germany
Robert J Sakimano and Trapper Gus like this post
Re: Immigration reform?
gomersbro wrote:Trapper Gus wrote:The anti - immigrant people in this country remind me of the rich people who want to eliminate all the support systems that helped them get rich.
Plus, without immigrants the economy would be in the dumps.
My argument for a progressive tax policy is somewhat analogous. On taxes, it is the rich need to pay more because they have the most to lose when society collapses. With immigrants, it is we need to be accommodating because no one is going to do the jobs we need to keep our society from collapsing.
The wealthy have nothing to lose. If America goes to shit, they'll just move to their bunker in New Zealand or Hawaii or the Moon or wherever the hell they want. They will leave you behind in the rubble.
TravelinMan- Geronte
- Posts : 2497
Join date : 2014-04-16
Re: Immigration reform?
TravelinMan wrote:gomersbro wrote:
My argument for a progressive tax policy is somewhat analogous. On taxes, it is the rich need to pay more because they have the most to lose when society collapses. With immigrants, it is we need to be accommodating because no one is going to do the jobs we need to keep our society from collapsing.
The wealthy have nothing to lose. If America goes to shit, they'll just move to their bunker in New Zealand or Hawaii or the Moon or wherever the hell they want. They will leave you behind in the rubble.
So what’s the downside in that scenario?
If by some sort of miracle Trumps able to make good on his deporting 11 million poor brown people (only bullshit low hanging fruit racists actually believe it can happen), what do you think will happen to Florida? Those rich folk got it all figured out, right? The poors aren't needed, right? Those STD passing MAGA types in the villages will be fine, right? Those patriots in their grossly overvalued homes will survive, right?
kingstonlake- Geronte
- Swill Pick 'em 2022 Extended Season Champion
- Posts : 27809
Join date : 2014-05-15
Age : 60
Re: Immigration reform?
did he build the wall that Mexico paid for yet?kingstonlake wrote:TravelinMan wrote:
The wealthy have nothing to lose. If America goes to shit, they'll just move to their bunker in New Zealand or Hawaii or the Moon or wherever the hell they want. They will leave you behind in the rubble.
So what’s the downside in that scenario?
If by some sort of miracle Trumps able to make good on his deporting 11 million poor brown people (only bullshit low hanging fruit racists actually believe it can happen), what do you think will happen to Florida? Those rich folk got it all figured out, right? The poors aren't needed, right? Those STD passing MAGA types in the villages will be fine, right? Those patriots in their grossly overvalued homes will survive, right?
I bet if you asked republicans/libertarians, they'd cheer and say 'yes he did, 'cause he's a man of his word' -
Robert J Sakimano- Geronte
- Posts : 52014
Join date : 2014-04-15
Re: Immigration reform?
kingstonlake wrote:TravelinMan wrote:
The wealthy have nothing to lose. If America goes to shit, they'll just move to their bunker in New Zealand or Hawaii or the Moon or wherever the hell they want. They will leave you behind in the rubble.
So what’s the downside in that scenario?
If by some sort of miracle Trumps able to make good on his deporting 11 million poor brown people (only bullshit low hanging fruit racists actually believe it can happen), what do you think will happen to Florida? Those rich folk got it all figured out, right? The poors aren't needed, right? Those STD passing MAGA types in the villages will be fine, right? Those patriots in their grossly overvalued homes will survive, right?
That's all above my pay grade, Boss. I was just pointing out the flawed logic that the wealthy care anything at all about your cute little "society." If you want to get into a debate about how it's OK we pay illegals poverty wages to keep the comforts of society, that's for someone else to care about.
TravelinMan- Geronte
- Posts : 2497
Join date : 2014-04-16
Re: Immigration reform?
"If you're in trouble, or hurt or need - go to the poor people. They're the only ones that'll help - the only ones".
Steinbeck - The Grapes of Wrath
Robert J Sakimano- Geronte
- Posts : 52014
Join date : 2014-04-15
Trapper Gus likes this post
Similar topics
» The Proposed New Tax Reform
» This tax “reform” is going to pass.
» GOP tax reform might prevent Bob from writing off his massive donations to MSU athletics
» If we're gonna do this immigration ban/restriction thing...
» Federal weed reform is dead for now and will be for awhile
» This tax “reform” is going to pass.
» GOP tax reform might prevent Bob from writing off his massive donations to MSU athletics
» If we're gonna do this immigration ban/restriction thing...
» Federal weed reform is dead for now and will be for awhile
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum