My Soup Rankings

10. Italian Wedding
9. Miso
8. Chicken Noodle
7. Hot n Sour
6. Pho
5. Chicken tortilla
4. Beef barley
3. Chicken Lemon Rice
2. Wonton
1. Gumbo

YMMV

Why’s your beef with clam chowder

Too creamy. Manhattan is ok.

No clam chowder. List is invalid.

WhiteBoyHatcher wrote:Too creamy. Manhattan is ok.

You can make it less creamy if you want wbh

No Lobster Bisque either. List fails.

1) French Onion
2) Broccoli Cheddar
3) Beef barley
4) Cream of Broccoli
5) Vegetable
6) Minestrone
7) Chicken and Rice
8) Chicken Tortilla
9) Pho
10) Matzo Ball Soup

Is ramen soup or is ramen, ramen?

What the phuk is pho?

You’re kidding, right Floyd? Jesus Christ.

Floyd Robertson wrote:What the phuk is pho?

Awesome is what it is.

No love for Split Pea with bacon?

Broccoli Cheddar is my favorite soup, but I'm really not much for soups, in general. Stews are a little more my style, but I don't eat much stew either.

I have not had PHO.  My list, but I mostly eat just canned soup.

10 Potato and bacon
9 Chicken Noodle
8 Split Pea
7 Chicken Pot Pie soup
6 Broccoli Cheddar w/ Chicken
5 Hot N Sour
4 Miso
3 Lentil Soup w/ bacon
2 Clam Chowder
1 Lobster Bisque

I’d like to add Minestrone and loaded baked potatoe to the thread. Oh and traditional Greek bean soup.

My wife and I always say "we both love soup". It's our little joke. But I DO actually love soup.

WhiteBoyHatcher wrote:10. Italian Wedding
9. Miso
8. Chicken Noodle
7. Hot n Sour
6. Pho
5. Chicken tortilla
4. Beef barley
3. Chicken Lemon Rice
2. Wonton
1. Gumbo

YMMV

2-5 I might shift around, but this is a damn good list. It's soup weather bitches!

Rocinante wrote:My wife and I always say "we both love soup".  It's our little joke.  But I DO actually love soup.

WhiteBoyHatcher wrote:10. Italian Wedding
9. Miso
8. Chicken Noodle
7. Hot n Sour
6. Pho
5. Chicken tortilla
4. Beef barley
3.  Chicken Lemon Rice
2. Wonton
1. Gumbo

YMMV

2-5 I might shift around, but this is a damn good list. It's soup weather bitches!

No, Roc, it is not a good list, as stated elsewhere in this thread.

My opinion is the only one that matters to me.

AvgMSUJoe wrote:tWife make a "lasagna soup" with sausage that's pretty awesome.

No bacon potato cheddar? That's the shit if done right.

I had a "stew" (they called it) in San Fran that was essentially a tomato based soup with mussels, lobster, fish like years ago and I still pine for that shit.

Sounds like cioppino, which I believe originated from Italian-Americans in San Fran.

Rustic Italian tortellini . End of discussion

Cameron wrote:Broccoli Cheddar is my favorite soup, but I'm really not much for soups, in general. Stews are a little more my style, but I don't eat much stew either.

a bowl of liquid cheese is not soup

Banks2Mason wrote:

Cameron wrote:Broccoli Cheddar is my favorite soup, but I'm really not much for soups, in general. Stews are a little more my style, but I don't eat much stew either.

a bowl of liquid cheese is not soup

But if you put some broccoli in there, it counts.

I.B. Fine wrote:No love for Split Pea with bacon?

Love split pea...usually make it with smoked ham hocks or leftover ham.  Make navy bean soup with the same.

Black bean soup is good.  Will usually order that if it's on a restaurant menu.

As said, no soup list is complete without New England clam chowder.  Manhattan chowder sucks.  No actual dog in the fight but Boston>>>>>New York

Beet soup is awesome.  Always a bit of a shock when you take a shit the next day and there appears to be blood in your stool.  Real memory jogger.

Other honorable mention soups:
Mushroom
Asparagus
Potato/leek

Even some cold ones:
Cucumber
Gazpacho

WhiteBoyHatcher wrote:10. Italian Wedding
9. Miso
8. Chicken Noodle
7. Hot n Sour
6. Pho
5. Chicken tortilla
4. Beef barley
3.  Chicken Lemon Rice
2. Wonton
1. Gumbo

YMMV

Could you please list your favorite local places for #1 thru 4?